ICMCTF1999 Session D1-2: Synthesis, Characterization and Applications of Cubic Boron Nitride and Carbon Nitride Materials

Thursday, April 15, 1999 8:30 AM in Room Forum/Senate/Committee

Thursday Morning

Time Period ThM Sessions | Abstract Timeline | Topic D Sessions | Time Periods | Topics | ICMCTF1999 Schedule

Start Invited? Item
8:30 AM D1-2-1 Is Carbon Nitride Fullerene-like?
G.A.J. Amaratunga (Cambridge University, UK); C.J. Kiely, I. Alexandrou (Liverpool University, UK); M. Chhowalla (Cambridge University, UK); M. Akiyama (Kyushu National Industrial Research Institute, Japan)

Research on carbon nitride was initially inspired by the predicted properties of its cubic from C3N4. Its synthesis in a homogeneous form remains to be achieved. However, in the attempt to achieve this a new class of CNx thin film materials have been found. In many studies CNx is found to exhibit unique mechanical properties. In particular, it appears to have "hard and elastic" properties under loading conditions which normally lead to significant plastic deformation in other hard films, e.g. terahedral amorphous carbon.

Structural studies on CNx films show that those with interesting mechanical properties are not completely amorphous. Residual structure in the form of curved graphene sheet fragments are evident. Analysis of bonding using EELS also shows that the hardness cannot be associated with high degree of "diamond-like" bonding. Recent studies also show that well formed carbon nanotube-like and onion-like structures can also be present within the CNx matrix. Results obtained to date from a number of groups are reviewed. New results which show that the "amorphous" matrix in CNx can also show interlinked curved graphene plane structure are also presented. The evidence available to date suggests that a new fullerene-like can be obtained in CNx films deposited under certain conditions

9:10 AM D1-2-3 Growth Kinetic Studies to the Carbon Nitride Film Formation by Reactive rf Magnetron Sputtering
R. Kaltofen, T. Sebald (Institute of Solid State and Materials Research Dresden, Germany)
The formation of carbon nitride is still to be well understood, especially when chemically reactive plasmas are used for film synthesis. This paper deals with the effects of growth processes on the compositional and structural features of CNx films deposited by rf magnetron sputtering of graphite in nitrogen noble gas discharges. The neutral and ionic particle fluxes incident on the film were analyzed for various sputter conditions using quantitative and energy-resolved mass spectrometry. These data were related to the chemical composition and bonding structure of the films studied by several analytic methods. The condensation kinetics of sputtered C atoms was found to be favored over the reaction kinetics between N and C resulting always in a sp2/sp3 hybridized carbon matrix. The incorporation mechanisms of nitrogen into this matrix are governed by the arriving fluxes of N and C atoms, ΦN,C on the growing surface. For low ΦNC ratios, N atoms are exlusively incorporated up to 25 at% as substitutions of C atoms in graphitic clusters. In addition to this mechanism, the relative excess of atomic nitrogen at high ΦNC forces the formation of aliphatic type CN structures leading to a further increase of the N content. An intensive ion bombardment during the film growth results in a reduced production of linear N-sp2C bonds due to an enhanced desorption of N atoms, mainly, however, in an amorphization of the films. These changes were accompanied by decreasing mass densities and Young's moduli.'
9:30 AM D1-2-4 Growth, Structure and Mechanical Properties of CNxHy Films Deposited by d.c. Magnetron Sputtering in N2/Ar/H2 Discharges
N. Hellgren, M.P. Johansson (Linköping University, Sweden); B. Hjörvarsson (Royal Institute of Technology, Sweden); E. Broitman, T. Berlind, L. Hultman, J.-E. Sundgren (Linköping University, Sweden)

Hydrogenated carbon nitride films were deposited by reactive d.c. magnetron sputtering in mixed N2/Ar/H2 discharges. CNxHy films were grown onto Si (001) substrates kept at substrate temperatures of either 100 or 350 °C. The total pressure was kept constant at 2,5 mTorr with gas mixtures of Ar/H2, N2/H2 or Ar/N2(5%)/H2 and with the H2 fraction varied from 0 to 20%. As-deposited films were analyzed with respect to their microstructure, chemical structure and mechanical properties by HREM, SEM, RBS, NRA, XPS, FTIR and Raman spectroscopy, and Nanoindentation.

It was found that the growth rate for all films, except those grown in Ar/H2 discharge at low temperature, decreased with increasing H2 partial pressure. With more than ~15 - 20 % H2 in the gas, no net film growth took place, which can be attributed to chemical etching effects on the growth surface. As a result, species like CH4, C2H2, NH3 and C2N2 were observed by mass-spectrometry during growth. The amount of hydrogen in the films, as observed by nuclear reaction analysis, was found to increase with increasing H2 partial pressure, while the nitrogen concentration decreased slightly, indicating that more carbon bonds become terminated by hydrogen, as also reflected by a narrower C1s XPS peak as less carbon-nitrogen bonds are present. High resolution transmission electron microscopy also shows that films grown in nitrogen at elevated temperature undergoes a transition from a fullerene-like to a more polymeric microstructure as the amount of hydrogen is increased. The mechanical response, as measured by nanoindentation, also changes from being hard and highly elastic, to more moderate values typical for hydrogenated carbon films.

9:50 AM D1-2-5 Sputtering and Chemical Erosion During CNx Synthesis by Ion Beam Assisted Filtered Arc Evaporation
F. Richter, C. Spaeth (Technische Universität Chemnitz, Germany); U. Kreissig (Forschungszentrum Rossendorf, Germany)

Carbon nitride (CNx) thin films have been prepared by cathodic arc evaporation of a graphite cathode under simultaneous bombardment of the growing film by a nitrogen ion beam produced by a Kaufmann-type source. Film deposition was performed varying the ratio of arrival rates of nitrogen and carbon ions, Qr, the energy of the nitrogen ion beam as well as temperature and bias potential of the substrate. For comparision, film deposition was performed without nitrogen ion beam by operating the carbon arc in a nitrogen atmosphere of appropriate pressure. Film composition was analyzed using elastic recoil detection (ERD) analysis.

For each deposition condition the fluences of carbon and nitrogen atoms were calculated from the ion currents. Comparing these fluences to the number of atoms per unit area found by the ERD analysis the sticking coefficients for carbon and nitrogen could be obtained. In addition, the knowledge of the number of atoms per area was used to determine the density of the samples.

Usually, a reduction of the incorporated rates in comparision to the arrival rates was observed both for nitrogen and carbon. A major reason for that is sputtering which, however, cannot explain the full difference quantitatively. Therefore an additional chemical mechanism has to be assumed. Most probably this mechanism consists of the formation of volatile (CN)2 supported by the dissociation and excitation of neutral nitrogen species contained in the background gas atmosphere by the arc plasma. At increasing Qr the incorporation of nitrogen is more hampered than that of carbon. This is probably due to the formation and out-diffusion of N2 molecules.

10:30 AM D1-2-7 Crystalline Carbon Nitride Growth in a Flowtube by Decomposition of Cyanogen Azide
C.J. Linnen, D.J. Benard (Rockwell Science Center)
The energetic precursor molecule cyanogen azide (NCN:NN) was synthesized by thermal reaction of solid sodium azide and cyanogen bromide upon heating the mixed solids to 60 °C. The azide gas was collected and diluted in helium before passing into a 1.5 inch ID subsonic quartz flowtube reactor, where it mixed on-the-fly with the afterglow of an electrically discharged stream of nitrogen and helium at a pressure of about 10 Torr. Transfer of vibrational energy from excited nitrogen molecules to the azide parent or donor species resulted in dissociation into NCN and molecular nitrogen daughter fragments, in which the nascent NCN radicals were obtained in a long-lived electronically excited metastable state with high quantum efficiency. Approximately 1 millisecond downstream from the point of azide injection and mixing with discharged nitrogen, the excited NCN radicals contributed to growth of optical quality semi-transparent carbon-nitrogen films on a 1 inch dia. substrate suspended in the reacting flow. Analysis of the films by XPS showed comparable mole fractions of diamond-like carbon and stoichiometric carbon nitride with a much smaller yield of process (bromine) impurity. Film depositions were made onto a wide variety of substrate materials at measured backside temperatures ranging from ambient up to 550 °C, and (under specific substrate / temperature conditions) subsequent X-ray diffraction measurements demonstrated sharp peaks with good S/N ratio that precisely correspond to oriented growth of beta-phase carbon nitride. Film stability and adhesion were also strongly influenced by these key deposition parameters. Growth rates as high as several microns per hour were obtained by operating the flowtube at plug-flow velocities of approximately 60 meters / second with an internal converging-diverging coaxial glass-filled teflon nozzle to concentrate active flow along the reactor centerline. This paper will present detailed optical, chemical, electrical and mechanical characterizations of the films so generated.
10:50 AM D1-2-8 Reactive Magnetron Sputtering of Carbon Nitride Films - Characterization of Ion Bombardment and Optical Emission Spectroscopy in a Deposition Zone
J. Vlcek, K. Rusnak, V. Hajek (University of West Bohemia, Czech Republic)

CNx films were deposited on Si(100) substrates using DC magnetron sputtering of a high-purity 99.99% graphite target in a pure 99.999% nitrogen at the pressure p in the range from 0.15 to 5 Pa and the constant gas flow of 75 sccm. The target-to-substrate distance was 100 mm. The discharge current on the target Im was in the range from 0.5 to 3 Å, the negative substrate bias voltage Ub induced by an RF generator operating at a frequency of 13.56 MHz varied from -300 to -1200 V and the substrate temperature Ts was 600 °C.

We prepared amorphous films, typically 1 to 2 µm thick, substoichiometric in nitrogen (N/C up to 0.35) with high hardness (up to 40 GPa), elastic recovery (up to 85%), good adhesion to substrates and good tribological properties.

Discharge characteristics were measured for both mutually coupled discharges (i.e., DC magnetron discharge and RF discharge dominant in a substrate region) and the corresponding L/li values, where L is the sheath thickness and li is the ion mean free path, were evaluated to provide information on the energies and fluxes of ions bombarding the target and growing films under various deposition conditions. Optical emission spectroscopy was used to study an occurrence of significant atomic and molecular species, such as N, N2, N+, N2+, CN, C and C2, near a substrate.

Excepting the values of /Ub/ higher than 700 V, for which the N/C atomic ratio in the films decreases at low pressures (mainly due to preferential sputtering of nitrogen from them) and the deposition rate of the films falls very rapidly at higher pressures, a good correlation between the N/CN concentration ratio in the deposition zone and the N/C ratio in the CNx films was found. It was shown that the films with a high N/C ratio can have a high hardness only in the case that the energy and flux of nitrogen ions, bombarding the growing films during their deposition, are sufficient for an effective incorporation of nitrogen into the films (/Ub/ = 500 to 700 V, Jm = 7.1 mA/cm2 and p < 0.5 Pa).

11:10 AM D1-2-9 Low Energy Plasma Beam Deposition of Carbon Nitride Layers: Influence of the Deposition Parameters on the Chemical and Structural Film Properties
H. Oechsner, F.R. Weber (Center of Materials Research and Institute for Surface and Thin Film Analysis, University of Kaiserslautern, Germany)

Electrically neutral, laterally homogeneous plasma beams in which the energy Eion of the ion component can be precisely varied from some 10 eV up to 1 - 2 keV have been shown to be a very suitable means for a controlled deposition of hard compound films /1/. For the deposition of carbon nitride films the source plasma was operated in nitrogen with admixtures of Ar /2/, but also of Ne, the latter components to enable controlled energy input during film growth. The carbon component was added by sputter injection into the source plasma from a large area graphite target. CN-films were grown on Si(100) for operating the plasma beam source with varying N2 to Ar or Ne ratios at Eion = 100 eV or 120 eV, respectively. The film composition was determined by SNMS, and N-concentrations around 45 at% were achieved when operating the source with pure N2. The binding conditions were studied with XPS. From a detailed analysis of the C1s- and N1s-peak structures the fraction with a binding configuration corresponding to a probably ß-C3N4 like phase was found to reach 0.58 for N2/Ar or Ne ratios around 1:2. By separating the contribution of that phase to the total peaks, an N/C-ratio around 1.33 in agreement with a C3N4-phase was always found for that fraction of the films. The optical band gap determined by spectroscopic ellipsometry displayed a maximum value slightly below 2 eV which coincides both with maximum film hardness and maximum content of the C3N4-phase. Further indication for the formation of a ß-C3N4 like phase was supplied by high energy electron diffraction delivering lattice spacings which agree well with corresponding theoretical predictions. Quite interestingly, a strong influence of the N+/N2+-ratio in the plasma beam was found which indicates that a hard C3N4-phase is preferentially formed by a well defined energy input via atomic nitrogen. } /1/ F.R. Weber, H. Oechsner, Surf. Coat. Technol. 59 (1993), 183 /2/ F.R. Weber, H. Oechsner, Surf. Coat. Technol. 75 (1995), 704 Electrically neutral, laterally homogeneous plasma beams in which the energy Eion of the ion component can be precisely varied from some 10 eV up to 1 - 2 keV have been shown to be a very suitable means for a controlled deposition of hard compound films /1/. For the deposition of carbon nitride films the source plasma was operated in nitrogen with admixtures of Ar /2/, but also of Ne, the latter components to enable controlled energy input during film growth. The carbon component was added by sputter injection into the source plasma from a large area graphite target. CN-films were grown on Si(100) for operating the plasma beam source with varying N2 to Ar or Ne ratios at Eion = 100 eV or 120 eV, respectively. The film composition was determined by SNMS, and N-concentrations around 45 at% were achieved when operating the source with pure N2. The binding conditions were studied with XPS. From a detailed analysis of the C1s- and N1s-peak structures the fraction with a binding configuration corresponding to a probably ß-C3N4 like phase was found to reach 0.58 for N2/Ar or Ne ratios around 1:2. By separating the contribution of that phase to the total peaks, an N/C-ratio around 1.33 in agreement with a C3N4-phase was always found for that fraction of the films. The optical band gap determined by spectroscopic ellipsometry displayed a maximum value slightly below 2 eV which coincides both with maximum film hardness and maximum content of the C3N4-phase. Further indication for the formation of a ß-C3N4 like phase was supplied by high energy electron diffraction delivering lattice spacings which agree well with corresponding theoretical predictions. Quite interestingly, a strong influence of the N+/N2+-ratio in the plasma beam was found which indicates that a hard C3N4-phase is preferentially formed by a well defined energy input via atomic nitrogen.

1. F.R. Weber, H. Oechsner, Surf. Coat. Technol. 59 (1993), 183

2. F.R. Weber, H. Oechsner, Surf. Coat. Technol. 75 (1995), 704

11:30 AM D1-2-10 Investigation of the Valence Band States of Reactively Sputtered Carbon Nitride Films
M.A. Monclus, D.C. Cameron (Dublin City University, Ireland); R. Barklie, M. Collins (Trinity College, Ireland); A.K.M.S Chowdhury (Dublin City University, Ireland)

The variation in the electrical properties of carbon nitride films deposited by a Penning-type opposed target reactive sputtering technique as a function of nitrogen incorporation was recently described 1. It was shown that the resistivity and activation energy of the films increase with nitrogen incorporation and this was related to a transition from metallic to semiconducting behavior. In this paper X-ray photoemission spectroscopy (XPS) and ultraviolet photoemission spectroscopy (UPS) are used to study the valence band spectra of the films. XPS studies do not give a good indication of the states responsible for conduction in the films due to cross-section modulation effects 2 . On the other hand, UPS is more sensitive to valence band states and gives a better approximation of the actual valence band spectra of the films. The resistivity of carbon nitride films is found to decrease with negative substrate bias. Electron spin resonance (ESR) is used to investigate the paramagnetic centres of these films; their electrical properties are discussed in terms of their bonding structure by examining what paramagnetic species give rise to the observed ESR spectra.

1 M.A. Monclus, D.C. Cameron, R. Barklie, M. Collins, presented in the 6th conference on Plasma Surface Engineering, Garmisch, Germany (Sept 14-18, 1998).

2 F.R. McFeely, S.P. Kowalczyk, L.Ley, R.G. Cavell, R.A. Pollak and D.A. Shirely, Phys. Rev. B, 9 (1974) 5268.

11:50 AM D1-2-11 Effect of Substrate Negative Bias on sp2 to sp3 Phase Transformation in Carbon Nitride Thin Film
A.K.M.S Chowdhury, D.C. Cameron, M.A. Monclus (Dublin City University, Ireland)
Continuous nanocrystalline ß-C3N4 thin films have recently been produced by opposed target Penning type DC magnetron sputtering technique1. In this paper, film structure and composition were investigated as a function of substrate negative bias, to observe changes in bonding structure. Structural changes were investigated by valence band XPS and Raman spectroscopy. The hardness of the films was measured by nanoindentation. It was found that the sp3 type nature of the film is maximised at a substrate negative bias range of 100 to 150V. The valence band XPS spectra of the film changed from polymeric to diamond-like at a threshold bias voltage of -100V. The hardness value of the film also maximises in this bias range. It was also seen that films become more sp2 bonded for substrate bias > -150V owing to excessive thermal heat generation due to bombardment by the highly energetic species2. The ratio of the Raman peaks due to the N band3 (IN) and the G band (IG) did not change in this bias range showing no loss of nitrogen by preferential sputtering. This shows that the N-N bonds are strong enough to withstand the thermal effects due to sputtering which indicates that these bonds form an integral part of the C-N network. We can therefore say that there is no loss of nitrogen due to preferential sputtering in contrast to previous reports4. It is also shown that valence band XPS spectroscopy is a much more sensitive indicator of structural changes than vibrational spectroscopy. 1. A.K.M.S. Chowdhury, D.C. Cameron, M.S.J. Hashmi, J.M. Gregg, submitted to Phys. Rev. Letts. 2. J. Robertson, Diamond and Related Mater., 3, 361 (1994). 3. A.K.M.S. Chowdhury, D.C. Cameron and M.S.J. Hashmi, in press, Thin Solid Films. 4. W. Zheng, T Ding, I. Ivanov and J.-E Sundgren, J. Mater. Sci. Technol., 13, 154 (1997).
Time Period ThM Sessions | Abstract Timeline | Topic D Sessions | Time Periods | Topics | ICMCTF1999 Schedule